2. Screening ages and frequencies
In the context of an organised screening programme, for:
- asymptomatic women
- aged 45 to 49
- with an average risk of breast cancer
the ECIBC's Guideline Development Group (GDG) suggests:
- mammography screening (conditional recommendation, moderate certainty of the evidence)
- either triennial or biennial mammography over annual screening (conditional recommendation, very low certainty of the evidence)
Women aged 45-49: screening vs. no screening
Issued on: September 2021
Healthcare question
Should organised mammography screening vs. no mammography screening be used for early detection of breast cancer in women aged 45 to 49?
Recommendation
For asymptomatic women aged 45 to 49 with an average risk of breast cancer, the ECIBC's Guidelines Development Group (GDG) suggests mammography screening over no mammography screening, in the context of an organised population-based screening programme.
Recommendation strength
Conditional recommendation |
Moderate certainty of the evidence |
Justification
The decision on this recommendation takes into account the balance between desirable and undesirable effects that probably favours organised mammography screening for women aged 45 to 49 in the context of moderate certainty of the evidence.
New evidence suggested that the cost-effectiveness probably favours organised mammography screening.
Subgroup considerations
This recommendation does not apply to women at higher risk of developing breast cancer, who are outside the scope of the European breast cancer guidelines.
Considerations for implementation and policy making
The GDG discussed how the implementation of the intervention may be challenged depending on the number of women included in the age range considered (i.e. adding 5 years for programs that are currently screening is less feasible than adding age groups by yearly strata) and the time interval used for screening (i.e. annual vs biennial).
Organisational issues and the backlog caused by the pandemic in the last years should also be considered.
Monitoring and evaluation
Within EC initiative on Breast Cancer, quality indicators to measure the performance of breast cancer screening programmes have been identified.
Research priorities
The GDG highlighted the importance of programmatic research in absence of trial data.
The GDG considered also as research priorities:
- Evaluating the effects of the intervention, time intervals, risk factors and stratification of women, as well as context specific cost-effectiveness in this age group, in particular countries or programmes that are already implementing this approach.
- Conducting studies addressing the role of other screening modalities in this population.
Supporting material